Klikk for å flage denne meldingensom misbruk

Hva er misbruk? (1) personangrep, (2) reklame, (3) spam. Se bruksvilkår.

Gruppe:  75 Books Challenge for 2009 ignore
Emne:  lindsacl's (Laura's) challenge - part 3 0 / 202 lest

aug 4, 2009, 1:36pm (topp)Message 1: lindsacl

aug 4, 2009, 1:38pm (topp)Message 2: lindsacl

47. Cold Comfort Farm - review

From my review: At 19, Flora Poste found herself orphaned and with almost no income or property. However, she approached this potentially dire situation with optimism, asking several distant relatives whether they would be able to take her in. She received several offers of varying degrees of merit, ultimately decided to make her home at Cold Comfort Farm, and very quickly moved from London to rural Sussex in southern England. ... There were many amusing situations described with clever prose. And yet, towards the end, the "over the top" nature of the characters began to wear on me, and I found it harder to suspend disbelief and just enjoy the book. However, this was a fun read and a nice break from heavier literature, and I can recommend it on that basis. (3 / 5 stars)

aug 4, 2009, 2:45pm (topp)Message 3: Donna828

I am honored to be the first to post in your newest thread, Laura. I have had Cold Comfort Farm in my wish notebook for quite a while now. It looks like a "comforting" read. Sorry, couldn't resist. I am taking a little breather from heavy lit as well. I'm reading an oldie by Faith Sullivan who writes of a simpler era, although her characters do have their troubles.

aug 4, 2009, 3:37pm (topp)Message 4: tiffin

It's funny how CCF hits different people, isn't it Laura. I would have given it a solid 4 but then her dry, wry way of poking fun at that whole genre of pastoral lit just cracked me up. Haven't seen the movie.

aug 4, 2009, 3:38pm (topp)Message 5: Whisper1

I think Cold Comfort Farm is one of Stasia's favorite books.

I checked it out of the library but had to return it before I finished. I'll try again.

aug 4, 2009, 3:46pm (topp)Message 6: tloeffler

That is one of those books that I could have sworn I had read, but the description doesn't sound at all familiar. Guess it'll have to go on the list. Along with six other books from this one session of post-reading. Sheesh.

aug 4, 2009, 7:03pm (topp)Message 7: rebeccanyc

I love Cold Comfort Farm but I read it for the first time during a very stressful period of my life and it was just what I needed, so that may color my feelings.

aug 4, 2009, 9:53pm (topp)Message 8: lindsacl

Thanks for all the comments on Cold Comfort Farm ! I have to say I'd read a lot of "hype" about it, and that probably raised my expectations to an unreasonably high level. It was enjoyable, but I was expecting more. But it was just right for summer as I've been seeking out lighter fare lately anyway.

aug 5, 2009, 6:46pm (topp)Message 9: pamelad

Laura, Cold Comfort Farm is a favourite of mine. It's a take-off of the gothic melodramas in fashion at the time, so there's no need to take the characters seriously.

aug 5, 2009, 9:37pm (topp)Message 10: lindsacl

>9: yeah, I got that it was all a send-up. And it was enjoyable, don't get me wrong!

aug 5, 2009, 9:54pm (topp)Message 11: tiffin

It's probably how I feel about slapstick, Laura. A kind of overkill switch flips and you want to inject everyone who is carrying on with pies and boards with some kind of muscle relaxant.

aug 6, 2009, 7:46am (topp)Message 12: lindsacl

>11: LOL! I love that description. In fact, "slapstick" was exactly what I was thinking of as I came to the end of the book. And I have the same visceral reaction to it as you.

aug 6, 2009, 10:51am (topp)Message 13: FlossieT

I think I like Cold Comfort Farm, despite my English teacher's misguided idea that before we could attempt it, we had to first slog through chunks of the dreadful rustic lit it satirises (cough D.H. Lawrence cough).

Back on your previous thread - the only du Maurier I've read thus far is Vanishing Cornwall, her non-fiction book about the region. Definitely must be fixed one day (although I have very unhappy memories of Jamaica In - the place - after stopping off there on a nightmarish trip down to stay with relatives... it's just off one of the main routes down to the county!). I like the sound of the NYRB short story volume that Rebecca recommended.

aug 7, 2009, 12:19pm (topp)Message 14: Prop2gether

I saw Cold Comfort Farm before I read it, and, for me that actually worked for the book. I had a visualization of the characters and the style which carried me through sections which were slow for me. So, I ended up enjoying both.

aug 8, 2009, 1:16am (topp)Message 15: alcottacre

Cold Comfort Farm is not one of my favorite books, although I like it a great deal. The movie version is very good - even my hubby liked it - we were laughing out loud at a lot of it. Thanks to Cariola for the recommendation of both the book and the movie last year.

aug 8, 2009, 8:25pm (topp)Message 16: lindsacl

48. Vernon God Little - review

From my review: Vernon Little is 15 when his friend Jesus opens fire on a group of classmates, killing 16 including himself. As one of the few survivors, Vernon becomes the town's scapegoat and is almost immediately charged as an accessory to the crime. This book, told from Vernon's point of view, describes the nightmare of his life in the months following the shooting. Surprisingly, it does so with considerable humor and irony. ... About two-thirds of the way through the book the storyline became a bit unbelievable, but the last 30 pages or so resolve things in a fairly satisfying way. Not a bad read. (3 / 5 stars)

aug 14, 2009, 8:49pm (topp)Message 17: lindsacl

49. Olive Kitteridge - review

From my review: Elizabeth Strout's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel centers around Olive and Henry Kitteridge, an older couple living in a small town in Maine, grappling with aging and the changes in the world around them. Good friends have died; young people are a mystery. Their son Christopher has married and moved away. The novel is actually a baker's dozen of short stories, each featuring Olive in some way. Sometimes the story is all about Olive; at other times she is but a passing figure seen on the stairs or on a balcony, or a casual observer of another's life story. ... While each of these stories can stand on its own, this book is wonderful when read cover-to-cover, as a novel. Full of rich characters and emotional impact, it will remain with me for some time. (4.5 / 5 stars)

aug 15, 2009, 1:04am (topp)Message 18: alcottacre

#17: Nice review of a very good book, Laura.

aug 15, 2009, 9:07am (topp)Message 19: Carmenere

I'm adding Olive to my wish list, I love good stories that stick with you for awhile. I'm not sure about Vernon, I had heard the title before but didn't know the plot, now that I do I just don't know.

aug 16, 2009, 6:09am (topp)Message 20: lindsacl

>19: I understand! It is an unusual book. I'd definitely recommend Olive over Vernon!

aug 16, 2009, 9:27am (topp)Message 21: Whisper1

Olive Kitteridge is on my tbr pile. After your excellet review, I'm reminded to move it up closer to the top.

Thanks.

aug 16, 2009, 10:26am (topp)Message 22: lindsacl

>21: you won't regret it!

aug 20, 2009, 4:53pm (topp)Message 23: lindsacl

50. Revolutionary Road - review

From my review: Frank and April Wheeler are a young married couple who have recently moved their young family from New York City to the Connecticut suburbs. They see themselves as a cut above the typical 1955 suburbanite. Evenings with their friends Milly & Shep Campbell are spent discussing "sophisticated" topics and mutually reinforcing their status. The book opens with April's lead role in a community theater production -- an attempt to bring culture to their community. The play is a colossal failure. Frank and April's reactions to failure are early indicators of the tension between them. ... And then things begin to unravel. I'll avoid spoilers, but suffice to say just when you think it can't get any worse, it does. Frank and April's relationship takes a dive of epic proportions, with widespread consequences. And when I suddenly saw where the whole thing was going, I was both riveted and deeply saddened. Yates' writing was just as effective in capturing the emotional turmoil of these two characters as he was in his satire. Highly recommended. (4 / 5 stars)

aug 20, 2009, 5:42pm (topp)Message 24: Whisper1

Great review...I'm adding this one to the ever growing tbr pile.

thanks!

aug 20, 2009, 7:13pm (topp)Message 25: Cait86

I bought Revolutionary Road a few months ago, and promptly forgot about it. Looks like I should move it up the TBR pile! I want to see the movie too, with Kate Winslet and Leo Dicaprio. I think it will be interesting to see how their chemistry and acting has developed since Titanic. Kate Winslet said that Revolutionary Road is one of her favourite books ever, and so she really wanted to adapt it for the screen.

Great review!

aug 20, 2009, 8:23pm (topp)Message 26: arubabookwoman

I read Revolutionary Road years ago, and am still haunted by the ending.

aug 21, 2009, 6:42am (topp)Message 27: lindsacl

>25: I have not seen the film either, mostly because I usually prefer to read the book first.
>26: I can understand that!

aug 21, 2009, 2:51pm (topp)Message 28: rebeccanyc

Having read and loved the book, it is almost impossible for me to imagine Winslet/Dicaprio doing it justice, or for that matter for a US film to have such a, as arubabookwoman puts it, haunting ending.

aug 22, 2009, 11:30pm (topp)Message 29: Whisper1

Hello and congratulations on your hot review, listed on today's home page, for Revolutionary Road!

aug 23, 2009, 12:07am (topp)Message 30: judylou

I have been thinking about reading Revolutionary Road for a while now. I am yet to see the movie, so I might have to get to it soon.

I really liked Vernon God Little. Almost everyone I know who has read it has disliked it, so I am pleased to see that you liked it as well. I thought it was very clever and I remember cringing through so much of it - just how did so much happen so undeservedly to one person??

aug 23, 2009, 6:22am (topp)Message 31: lindsacl

>30: just how did so much happen so undeservedly to one person?? yes I know what you mean, Judy. And yet some of it he brought on himself, simply because he was so naive and lacked any kind of adult support to cope with the crisis.

aug 23, 2009, 11:12am (topp)Message 32: Whisper1

I'm enjoying these posts regarding Revolutionary Road and need to read it asap.

aug 23, 2009, 6:33pm (topp)Message 33: lindsacl

I think you'd like it, Whisp!

aug 26, 2009, 12:27pm (topp)Message 34: lindsacl

51. I'm not Complaining - review

From my review: Madge Brigson is in her 30s, single by choice, and committed to the teaching profession. By day she manages a room full of primary school children; on certain evenings she also conducts classes for unemployed young women. The Nottinghamshire town of Bronton has been hit hard by the Great Depression; factories have closed and unemployment is high. Most of the students come from families who were already poor, and are now suffering even more. Despite the gloomy setting, there's a great deal of humor in this book. Adam provides amusing portrayals of parents, children, and townspeople, and takes shots at the government and the educational hierarchy ... There are moments of deep emotion; Madge herself has to cope with sudden tragedy, and the reader is right there, sharing her grief. Madge is also faced with some significant decisions that will set her course for some time to come. I was pleased with the way Adam handled these issues, ensuring Madge could serve as a role model for others in her day. (4 / 5 stars)

aug 27, 2009, 1:46pm (topp)Message 35: alcottacre

#34: That one looks very good, Laura. Thanks for the recommendation!

aug 27, 2009, 6:04pm (topp)Message 36: orangeena

I"ve been somehow missing your thread lately so I was delighted to see you and others were quite taken with Olive Kitteridge. Definitely one of my outstanding fiction reads of several years.

Now I shall be on the look out for Revolutionary Road as you have recommended it highly and I have come to much respect your reading choices and comments. As others have noted, Kate Winslett was consumed for some years with the prospect of getting a movie made after she read the book. Its terribly heavy though - will have to steel myself for all the baggage and turmoil!

aug 27, 2009, 8:43pm (topp)Message 37: tiffin

Good review, Laura. Must keep an eye open for that one.

aug 27, 2009, 10:05pm (topp)Message 38: lindsacl

>36: nice to see you here orangeena, and thank you for your kind comments!

aug 31, 2009, 9:01pm (topp)Message 39: lindsacl

52. Jenny Wren - review

From my review: After their father's death, Jenny and Dahlia Rendall move with their mother Louisa from the farm where they grew up, to the nearby town of Radstowe where Louisa plans to support them by taking lodgers in their home. Jenny and Dahlia mourn the loss of their erudite father, who married a woman from a "lower" class, regretted it, and did all he could to shield his daughters from the prejudice inherent in 1920s English society. Now the young women are are embarrassed by Louisa's "common" manner and reputation for promiscuity. Louisa is secretly glad to be out of an unhappy marriage but ill-equipped to live independently. She accepted a loan from Thomas Grimshaw, a local farmer with whom she previously had an affair. Grimshaw drops by frequently to remind them of their debt, which is another source of embarrassment to the young women. ... Jenny Wren was first published in 1932. The story of class difference is a fairly typical one, in which the protagonist learns that the best things in life were with them all along. Although the plot is a bit predictable, it is presented through a memorable cast of characters and fine writing. I'm looking forward to reading the sequel, The Curate's Wife. (3.5 / 5 stars)

aug 31, 2009, 11:33pm (topp)Message 40: tiffin

Good review, Laura. Interesting that we came from slightly different angles about it (and half a star difference hehe).

sep 1, 2009, 1:02pm (topp)Message 41: lindsacl

I know, Tui! I wrote my review and then, just before posting it in LT, I read yours. It prompted a few more thoughts and I modified my review accordingly. Reading the different angle always makes me appreciate a book more, too. I assume you've also reviewed The Curate's Wife but I'm restraining myself until I've finished the book!

sep 1, 2009, 5:55pm (topp)Message 42: laytonwoman3rd

#39. I'm not reading this post yet, because I'm not finished with the book myself. (Got sidetracked by The Turn of the Screw.

sep 1, 2009, 7:23pm (topp)Message 43: tiffin

You know, I don't think I did review The Curate's Wife. Very different from Jenny Wren but I liked it too.

sep 1, 2009, 9:16pm (topp)Message 44: lindsacl

>42: hey, yeah, I was wondering what happened to you and Jenny!
>43: I'm enjoying it, too. A nice bit of poking fun at the clergy in the first 50 pages.

sep 5, 2009, 3:36pm (topp)Message 45: lindsacl

53. The Curate's Wife - review

From my review:The Curate's Wife is a story of marriage. Dahlia and Cecil Sproat, the title couple, are newly married. Cecil adores Dahlia; she is affectionate but not passionate towards him. Dahlia chose marriage primarily in response to a strong desire to live away from her mother and stepfather. She also desperately misses her sister Jenny, who left town to live near a young antiques dealer, formerly a lodger in her mother's house. Dahlia doesn't share Cecil's spiritual views, and with her outspoken nature she finds it difficult to play the part of a curate's wife. ... Meanwhile, there is another couple worthy of attention: the vicar, Norman Doubleday, and his wife Flora. Their marriage is also explored in depth, with quite poignant results, but for most of the novel the couple provide comic relief. ... Emily Hilda Young is marvelous in her portrayal of both couples. The Curate's Wife is a sequel to Jenny Wren, and I found it a more mature work exploring more complex themes. A very good read. (4 / 5 stars)

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, sep 5, 2009, 3:37pm.

sep 6, 2009, 1:59am (topp)Message 46: alcottacre

#45: Nice review, Laura. Wish my local library had these books!

sep 6, 2009, 6:26am (topp)Message 47: lindsacl

>46: I really enjoy these Virago Modern Classics. I've been collecting them for a little over a year, finding them in used bookshops or on paperbackswap. And also swapping with LT members in the Virago Modern Classics group. Each work is a gem, a bit of lesser-known literature by a woman author. I'm glad Virago Press decided to resurrect and preserve the work of these women!

sep 6, 2009, 6:53am (topp)Message 48: alcottacre

#47: I only have one - Four Frightened People - that I read earlier this year and enjoyed. I will have to keep my eyes open for more.

sep 6, 2009, 9:41am (topp)Message 49: tiffin

Really good review, Laura. I'm glad you read the two books back to back - I felt it was like moving from youth to maturity with the two of them, a kind of innocence to experience duo, did you? You read with great acuity and then are able to express that well in your reviews, so that I always feel your reviews have a certain honesty about them, as well as being very helpful.

ETA: Bravo for your hot review!

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, sep 6, 2009, 10:33am.

sep 6, 2009, 2:33pm (topp)Message 50: lindsacl

>49: Gee, thanks! I agree about "moving from youth to maturity". Towards the end of the book it's mentioned that only one year had passed since their father's death. Jenny Wren opens immediately after his passing. I was surprised the two books take place within a year, because it felt like a longer time period and certainly personal growth for the characters that is rarely accomplished in a short time. Ah well, literary license I s'pose.

sep 6, 2009, 9:49pm (topp)Message 51: Whisper1

I noted your hot review on the home page and join Tiffin in congratulating you for a job well done!

sep 7, 2009, 6:39am (topp)Message 52: lindsacl

Thanks!

sep 7, 2009, 8:00pm (topp)Message 53: lindsacl

54. Jamaica Inn - review

From my review:After her mother's death, 23-year-old Mary Yellan goes to live with her Aunt Patience. Mary remembers Patience as a vibrant woman, and is shocked to see the effect of her marriage to Joss Merlyn, keeper of Cornwall's Jamaica Inn. Joss' violent, alcohol-infused rages have taken a toll on Patience, who cowers at the very sight of her husband. And Mary quickly learns that all is not right at Jamaica Inn ... enjoyed this book well enough; I was caught up in the story and kept sneaking off to read. Mary is a strong protagonist, unwilling to accept her circumstances. However, while I definitely appreciate a strong female lead to a mousy one, some of Mary's actions were unrealistic. The ending was also too neat and predictable. These two flaws make Jamaica Inn a 3-star book instead of 4-stars, but still recommended, especially for fans of gothic mysteries. (3 / 5 stars)

sep 11, 2009, 12:38am (topp)Message 54: tymfos

Jamaica Inn sounds like one that I'd enjoy -- and our local library has it! Thanks for the great review!

sep 12, 2009, 4:31pm (topp)Message 55: lindsacl

55. My Cousin Rachel - review

From my review:
Dear Mrs. Du Maurier,

I so enjoyed your classic novel, Rebecca, that I resolved to read more of your work. While I quite enjoyed Jamaica Inn, I feel compelled to tell you of my disappointment in My Cousin Rachel. I know Rebecca was a smashing success -- in fact, over 70 years later it is still your most famous and best-loved work -- but that's no excuse for rehashing the same characters and themes. ... Honestly, Mrs. Du Maurier, did you run out of creative inspiration in the thirteen years between these two novels? At least Rebecca offered suspense and unexpected plot twists. My Cousin Rachel was predictable from the beginning. ... What happened? Were you under pressure to publish another novel? Were you running out of steam after such a prolific career? I notice that you turned to short stories for a time after publishing My Cousin Rachel; perhaps you just needed a break.

I have not given up on you, Mrs. Du Maurier, far from it -- but I think I'll focus on your earlier work.
Fondly,
Laura
(2 / 5 stars)

sep 12, 2009, 4:45pm (topp)Message 56: tymfos

#55. I LOVED the format of your review! A big thumbs-up from me! (And I won't waste time with Cousin Rachel.)

sep 12, 2009, 4:51pm (topp)Message 57: christiguc

Laura, you may not be able to answer this question, but if you hadn't read Rebecca, what would you have thought of My Cousin Rachel?

sep 12, 2009, 5:07pm (topp)Message 58: allthesedarnbooks

Lmao at your letter to Ms. DuMaurier! Her short stories are pretty good, though, so if My Cousin Rachel made them happen...

sep 12, 2009, 6:11pm (topp)Message 59: Whisper1

I'm simply stopping by to wave hello. I've added The Curate's Wife to my wishlist.

sep 12, 2009, 6:55pm (topp)Message 60: lindsacl

Thanks all! Earlier today I was having an imaginary conversation with Mrs. Du Maurier and that's when I got the idea for my review. I appreciate the feedback!

>57: christiguc, it's hard to say, isn't it? I might have given it an additional star. Even if I hadn't picked up on the similarities, it did plod a bit and there wasn't much suspense.

>59: Whisper1, you won't be disappointed!

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, sep 12, 2009, 6:56pm.

sep 12, 2009, 7:36pm (topp)Message 61: tymfos

I just checked the home page, and you've got a Hot Review for My Cousin Rachel! Congratulations!

sep 12, 2009, 9:18pm (topp)Message 62: lindsacl

Aw, shucks.

sep 12, 2009, 9:34pm (topp)Message 63: tiffin

One of those thumbs is mine! Really got a kick out of the letter to Mrs. Du M. Just hope she doesn't answer.

sep 12, 2009, 10:02pm (topp)Message 64: Donna828

I also loved that unique review. I must have liked My Cousin Rachel a bit more than you as I gave it 3.5 stars. It has been quite a few years since I read Rebecca so the similarities weren't quite as grating to me.

sep 13, 2009, 12:22am (topp)Message 65: tymfos

#63 Really got a kick out of the letter to Mrs. Du M. Just hope she doesn't answer.

If she did, THAT would make for great Halloween reading! ;)

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, sep 13, 2009, 12:23am.

sep 14, 2009, 8:56pm (topp)Message 66: lindsacl

56. Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha - review

From my review: The narrator and title character of this story, 10-year-old Patrick Clarke, is a fairly typical Irish boy. He runs with a pack of boys, playing football and finding ample opportunities for mischief. He tolerates his younger brother Francis (nicknamed Sinbad), and barely pays attention to his younger sisters. Adults -- teachers, friends' parents, and his own parents -- are mysterious creatures. He understands little about the adult world, and cares little about it as well. That is, until the small cracks in his family structure widen into fissures, and then chasms. As the oldest child, Patrick assumes responsibility for maintaining a cohesive family environment, and believes he can influence and redirect the growing emotional tension between his parents. ... This was a touching, poignant story. (3 / 5 stars)

sep 16, 2009, 9:12pm (topp)Message 67: Whisper1

Laura
Yours is a dangerous thread for my tbr pile. I always enjoy your reviews and add many of your books to my list.

sep 21, 2009, 2:27pm (topp)Message 68: lindsacl

57. One of Ours - review

From my review: This is the story of Claude Wheeler, a young man who grew up on a Nebraska farm in the early 1900s. ... My copy of this book came from my local library and, unfortunately, the book jacket included huge spoilers in its first two sentences. This threatened to ruin the book for me, but I tried to make lemonade from these lemons. Since I already knew about some pivotal events in Claude's life, I read with a view toward understanding why this book won the 1923 Pulitzer Prize. ... Since One of Ours was published just a few short years after the end of World War I, it was received at a time when emotions were still quite raw. Cather's writing is, as always, superb. And her portrayal of an innocent farm boy who serves in battle would have struck a chord for just about anyone. Unfortunately once I knew how things would turn out there were sections that seemed to drag on endlessly. I probably would have given this book a higher rating had there not been spoilers ... frustrating! (3 / 5 stars)

sep 21, 2009, 11:57pm (topp)Message 69: orangeena

I've read almost everything Cather has written except this. I recently bought Library of America's edition of her early stories and novels which includes this and the big three Midwestern fictions.
I am eager to read it and with your analysis will move it right up on my list. I've always been curious why this, which won the Pulitzer, would have more or less faded into oblivion with the greatness of My Antonia and to a lesser extent SoftL and O Pioneers becoming her signature works.
Perhaps the timliness of her WWI story was more compelling then than now?

sep 22, 2009, 7:45am (topp)Message 70: lindsacl

>69: Perhaps the timliness of her WWI story was more compelling then than now? That's what I think, orangeena. I had the same question about why this work faded into oblivion. I do think it was all in the timing.

sep 24, 2009, 6:12pm (topp)Message 71: pamelad

Laura, I discovered Willa Cather this year, after picking My Antonia from the tbr pile, and have just finished Death Comes for the Archbishop. Despite the off-putting title, it's a warm and human story about two good men who re-establish the Catholic church in New Mexico. Will look for O Pioneers! now.

sep 24, 2009, 8:02pm (topp)Message 72: tiffin

I've been trying to find her Shadows on the Rock, which is set in Quebec City, ever since I read Death Comes for the Archbishop because she has a real ability to evoke a sense of place, so I am curious what she does with Quebec.

sep 24, 2009, 8:45pm (topp)Message 73: lindsacl

>71: I discovered her this year, too, thanks to the Monthly Author Reads group. I read The Professor's House and liked it a lot. I'm sure I'll read more of her work; she really brings the prairie to life.

sep 25, 2009, 12:40pm (topp)Message 74: lindsacl

58. The Long Goodbye - review

From my review: For quite some time now, my husband had been urging me to read "hard-boiled" detective fiction. And I chose this particular book because it won an Edgar Award, and is on the list of "1001 Books you Must Read Before you Die." Well, I have to say the only reason I made it all the way to the end was because I love my husband, and wanted to give this book a fair shake. But it really wasn't my cup of tea. (2 / 5 stars)

sep 25, 2009, 2:59pm (topp)Message 75: brenzi

Laura,
I do enjoy the occasional really well-written crime/detective novel but I'll take your advice on this one.

sep 25, 2009, 5:18pm (topp)Message 76: cmt

Just catching up on your thread and laughing at your reason for reading The Long Goodbye! You summed up beautifully my reason for reading some Murakami earlier this year. I made it to the end of that, too, but it was a struggle!

I do like detective fiction but might skip The Long Goodbye in favour of my depressed Scandinavian friends Wallander and Erlendur.

sep 25, 2009, 9:13pm (topp)Message 77: lindsacl

>76: In fact, after I delivered my verdict on Chandler, Mr. lindsacl suggested I try reading some Wallander (well, Henning Mankell really)!! Someday, someday ... we both enjoyed the recent dramatization with Kenneth Branagh but I still wasn't rushing to read the books. I also have a feeling my dear one wouldn't enjoy Viragos as much as I do. So perhaps we should just appreciate our diversity!!

sep 25, 2009, 10:01pm (topp)Message 78: tiffin

#77: don't you love it when a plan comes together! hehe

sep 27, 2009, 7:17am (topp)Message 79: lindsacl

>78: :))

sep 27, 2009, 9:19am (topp)Message 80: LisaCurcio

>72: Tui, Shadows on the Rock is just as good as the others, IMHO.

sep 27, 2009, 8:05pm (topp)Message 81: lindsacl

59. The Snow Geese - review

From my review: While recovering from a serious health issue, Fiennes read a classic story from his childhood, Paul Gallico's The Snow Goose. This sparked an interest in birds, and a strong desire to see snow geese first-hand. He decided to travel from his native England to Texas, and follow the geese the full length of their spring migration. Although he expected to keep pace with the geese, sometimes he arrived at his next stage well ahead of the birds, who would stop traveling if weather conditions were less than ideal. For Fiennes, the journey was spiritual as well as physical. As the geese flew by the thousands to their northern breeding ground, Fiennes was on a path to emotional recovery, repairing a soul shaken by his illness. ... This was a beautiful, moving book. Highly recommended. (5 / 5 stars)

sep 28, 2009, 3:53am (topp)Message 82: alcottacre

#81: It looks like a wonderful book. Thanks for the recommendation, Laura.

sep 29, 2009, 4:52pm (topp)Message 83: Whisper1

ditto what Stasia said

sep 29, 2009, 8:11pm (topp)Message 84: lindsacl

60. The Uncommon Reader - review

From my review: Alan Bennett's wonderful novella imagines what would happen if the Queen suddenly became an avid reader. When her much-loved corgis get loose and charge into a mobile library, Queen Elizabeth II charges in after them, and then feels an obligation to check out a book. And thus begins her obsession with reading; her discovery of great literature. ... The Uncommon Reader was a wonderful diversion that could be read again and again with enjoyment. (4 / 5 stars)

sep 29, 2009, 8:20pm (topp)Message 85: Whisper1

You are on a roll with great books!

sep 29, 2009, 9:23pm (topp)Message 86: cmt

#81 Laura, I read The Snow Geese a few years ago and loved it too. It's one of the few books that my husband and I both loved!

I also loved The Snow Goose - I think it was very widely read in NZ by my parents' generation (1950s). Mum still has her copy.

sep 30, 2009, 12:55pm (topp)Message 87: lindsacl

I saw a dramatization of The Snow Goose on television as a kid, and it tore me up. Despite that, I was inspired to read it and now have the book waiting for me at my library.

okt 10, 2009, 5:07pm (topp)Message 88: lindsacl

61. Empire Falls - review

From my review: The novel unfolds at a slow pace, with Russo first painting detailed portraits of all the major characters. Then there are occasional chapters in which Miles remembers events from his past. These episodes are retold from Miles' point of view at the time. Memories of a childhood vacation, or of learning to drive, are described with the perspective of a child, who may not always understand the intricacies of adult relationships or of "real life." Yet it's through these episodes that the reader begins to see how and why the Roby and Whiting families have become intertwined. ... Reading Empire Falls, I began to feel as if I knew these people. I found myself thinking about them when I wasn't reading; they were very real to me and will likely linger in my memory for some time. (4.5 / 5 stars)

62. The Snow Goose - review

From my review: Philip Rhayader lived alone in a lighthouse in the marshes of Essex, in England. Alone, he tended birds in his sanctuary, and painted the surrounding landscape. One day, a young girl named Frith brought him an injured snow goose. The goose had been blown off course during its annual migration in Canada. Then, on landing in the marsh, she was shot by hunters. Rhayader rehabilitated and released the bird, and then something highly unusual happened: the snow goose returned year after year. ... This may be a children's book, but its lessons of love, friendship, and valor are timeless and just as meaningful for adult readers. (5 / 5 stars)

okt 10, 2009, 8:40pm (topp)Message 89: tiffin

I bawled my heart out at the end of The Snow Goose, Laura. I wonder if it would hit me that way 50 years later?

okt 10, 2009, 9:36pm (topp)Message 90: lindsacl

Tui, I saw a dramatization once as a child and it has haunted me ever since. I was VERY teary reading the book, perhaps 35-40 years later. So, I'd say yes.

okt 11, 2009, 4:45am (topp)Message 91: alcottacre

#88: The Snow Goose is heading to Planet TBR. Thanks for the recommendation, Laura.

okt 11, 2009, 7:24am (topp)Message 92: lindsacl

>91: at less than 50 pages (it's a children's book), it's a really quick read.

okt 11, 2009, 8:05am (topp)Message 93: juliette07

Yes, the Snow Goose was, and still is, in the library of my parents. I read it as a child and am now going to search it out again. Ths library of my parents is now contained in a series of very large plastic storage boxes in our garage.

okt 11, 2009, 8:09am (topp)Message 94: alcottacre

#92: Oh, I did not realize it was that short, not that it matters anyway. I pick up books for their content, not their length (or lack thereof), lol.

okt 11, 2009, 10:13am (topp)Message 95: lindsacl

BTW, I was inspired to read The Snow Goose after reading the wonderful memoir, The Snow Geese. The author of this memoir was inspired by the children's book to follow the migratory journey of North American Snow Geese. I gave the memoir 5 stars as well -- see message #81 ...

okt 12, 2009, 3:00am (topp)Message 96: alcottacre

I had already added The Snow Geese before based on your review. Both books look very good to me!

okt 12, 2009, 5:19am (topp)Message 97: VisibleGhost

Book # 61- Empire Falls- Sometime in the future, instead of teaching how to write characterization, professors may just hand out Empire Falls and say, learn from this.

okt 12, 2009, 7:52am (topp)Message 98: lindsacl

>97: so true! I love character-driven novels and this one really exceeded my expectations. Fabulous stuff.

okt 12, 2009, 7:54am (topp)Message 99: FlossieT

>95 William Fiennes has a new memoir out (in the UK, at least), The Music Room, which has had some very approving reviews.

okt 12, 2009, 1:42pm (topp)Message 100: laytonwoman3rd

I loved Empire Falls, and now I want to read it again. Did any of you see the movie? Ed Harris played Miles, Paul Newman romped through the role of Max...Joanne Woodward, Helen Hunt and Philip Seymour Hoffman were in it too. A minor cast...

okt 12, 2009, 4:55pm (topp)Message 101: lindsacl

>100: oh my, that's a great cast!

okt 14, 2009, 1:02pm (topp)Message 102: lindsacl

63. Disgrace - review

From my review: David Lurie is a 50-something university professor, twice divorced. He's not particularly skilled at relationships. Perhaps he doesn't even understand what a relationship truly is, since early on he assumes that weekly encounters with a prostitute constitute some kind of more permanent bond. When the prostitute leaves town, David finds himself without female companionship and makes the even more egregious error of striking up an affair with a student. Of course this is discovered, and David leaves the university in disgrace. He visits his adult daughter Lucy, who runs a small farm and dog kennel in a rough and sometimes dangerous part of rural South Africa. ... David is not a particularly likable character. He is so interpersonally inept that he nearly always makes the wrong choice. I didn't really care whether he recovered from his ordeal; in many cases he got what he deserved. ... Disgrace raised up many ethical and moral issues, prompting me to consider how I might handle similar situations. Interesting reading. (3 / 5 stars)

okt 14, 2009, 1:49pm (topp)Message 103: brenzi

Laura, You're too kind. I can't tell you how much I disliked this book. You pointed out the fact that it raised many moral and ethical questions. You're right. Great review.

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, okt 14, 2009, 1:51pm.

okt 14, 2009, 2:02pm (topp)Message 104: Whisper1

I gave your review of the Snow Goose a thumbs up! Now, I've added it to the ever growing tbr pile.

I always find such great books when I visit your thread.

okt 14, 2009, 3:58pm (topp)Message 105: lindsacl

>103: Bonnie, I expected to HATE Disgrace. I'm still surprised I didn't !
>104: aw, shucks. Thanks!

okt 15, 2009, 10:17am (topp)Message 106: alcottacre

#102: I have that one at my house (somewhere) to read. I picked it up after I so enjoyed Coetzee's The Life and Times of Michael K, but have not managed to get to it yet. Based on your review, I think I will put it off a bit longer.

okt 15, 2009, 9:56pm (topp)Message 107: tiffin

Laura, I have Disgrace sitting here. Every now and then I cast a glance at it and somehow never quite pick it up. Someone at the Uni recommended it, just raving about Coetzee as the best modern writer in the world, etc., etc., several years ago. And still it sits.

okt 16, 2009, 9:33am (topp)Message 108: lindsacl

>107: kiwidoc is a huge Coetzee fan, and I respect her opinions, but he's not one of my favorites. To be fair the only book of his I'd read before was Elizabeth Costello, which bored me and I didn't finish it. Disgrace was a bit better -- 3 stars is still an OK read -- but I'm not going to go out and buy everything he's ever written.

okt 17, 2009, 8:15pm (topp)Message 109: lindsacl

64. Rites of Passage - review

From my review: When Edmund Talbot leaves England on a ship bound for Australia, he begins a journal dedicated to his godfather and patron. In it he records details of daily life and detailed descriptions of the passengers and crew (many of whom are quite interesting characters). He takes pride in learning maritime vocabulary; that is, once he has overcome extreme seasickness. As a member of the educated upper class he remains at arms' length from most of the passengers and views events with amusement and a certain detached superiority. His social interactions are limited primarily to Summers, an unusually well-spoken officer. ... This book is the first of a trilogy which was made into a BBC dramatization, To the Ends of the Earth. The story in Rites of Passage was the best part of the dramatization for me, and even though it was familiar I still enjoyed reading this book. (3.5 / 5 stars)

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, okt 19, 2009, 2:21pm.

okt 18, 2009, 11:29pm (topp)Message 110: alcottacre

I have never read anything of Golding's beyond Lord of the Flies, so I will check that one out. I may check out the BBC video as well. Thanks for the recommendation and review, Laura.

okt 21, 2009, 8:41pm (topp)Message 111: lindsacl

65. To the Lighthouse - review

From my review: This classic Virginia Woolf novel is such a "mood piece." Comprised of three major sections, To the Lighthouse is predominantly a portrait of the Ramsey family and its influential, beautiful matriarch. Most of the "action" (and I use that term loosely) takes place at a summer home off the coast of Scotland. ... And what happens, exactly? Not much. And yet, somehow, I was entranced by this family's life, from being made up of little separate incidents which one lived one by one, became curled and whole like a wave which bore one up with it and threw one down with it, there, with a dash on the beach (p. 47) This is a book best read, and re-read, and savored to glean new details and insights each time. (4 / 5 stars)

okt 21, 2009, 8:52pm (topp)Message 112: Whisper1

What a great review of To The LIghthouse.

okt 21, 2009, 10:25pm (topp)Message 113: tiffin

Laura, you've made me want to read To the Lighthouse again. I haven't read it since the early 70s so it's about time.

okt 22, 2009, 8:22am (topp)Message 114: lindsacl

>113: Tui, it was my first time. And now I can understand why I've heard/read others talk about rereading.

okt 22, 2009, 9:39am (topp)Message 115: Donna828

With all this talk about rereads, I just realized that every book I've read this year was new to me. I've been neglecting my old friends! To The Lighthouse is being taken from the shelf and placed on the coffee table as a reminder to take the time to visit Scotland again. Nice review, Laura.

okt 22, 2009, 10:56am (topp)Message 116: brenzi

Laura,

I've never read this Virginia Woolf book and I know it's one of those "I should read that" books so your great review kicked it up on the TBR pile.

okt 22, 2009, 12:47pm (topp)Message 117: lindsacl

>116: Bonnie, I found it helped to know "what I was getting into," so to speak. At some point early on I re-read Nickelini's comments on her 75-book thread and it recalibrated my expectations. From that moment I just kind of wallowed in it.

okt 24, 2009, 1:32am (topp)Message 118: alcottacre

I am with Tui - you have made me want to read it again!

okt 31, 2009, 8:50pm (topp)Message 119: lindsacl

66. Wolf Hall - review

From my review: I was thrilled to get my hands on the 2009 Booker Prize winner within just a few weeks of its US release. The first ten pages included a detailed cast of characters and a Tudor family tree, a sure sign I was diving into a rich, detailed saga. I hunkered down and was hooked from the first line, uttered by Walter Cromwell to his young son Thomas: "So now get up." From this point -- lying dazed and bloody on the pavement -- Thomas Cromwell rises to become one of King Henry VIII's most trusted advisers. (4.5 / 5 stars)

okt 31, 2009, 8:54pm (topp)Message 120: marise

Excellent review! I am only about half way through and love it.

okt 31, 2009, 8:57pm (topp)Message 121: brenzi

Oh Laura I love your review. I'm waiting for my copy from the library but they hadn't even ordered it when I called the acquisition dept. to see why I couldn't bring it up on the website! Somebody was asleep at the wheel. Anxiously waiting and pretty sure I'll like it since you do.

Came back to say congratulations on the hot review!

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, nov 1, 2009, 2:11pm.

okt 31, 2009, 9:36pm (topp)Message 122: orangeena

waiting...waiting...waiting for my name to come up on the library list. Don't know if I can hold out...the NY Times has a great review in tomorrow's paper.

nov 1, 2009, 6:24am (topp)Message 123: lindsacl

>122: that sounds funny, orangeena, as if you are predicting the future!
But yes, here's the NYT Book Review. I'd give this review a thumbs up as well!

nov 1, 2009, 1:05pm (topp)Message 124: Whisper1

Denne meldingen har blitt slettet av forfatteren.

nov 1, 2009, 1:08pm (topp)Message 125: Whisper1

Thanks for the NYT book review site. Now, I feel as though I have to rush to buy the book. Thanks also for your excellent review.

nov 4, 2009, 8:36pm (topp)Message 126: lindsacl

67. Le Grand Meaulnes - review

From my review: Le Grand Meaulnes is a romantic coming-of-age tale, a story of friendship, love, and loss. When Augustin Meaulnes arrives at a small French school, he is befriended by François Seurel, the 15-year-old son of the headmaster. François looks up to Meaulnes, who is two years older and both a dreamer and a rebel. The boys nickname him "Le Grande Meaulnes" which the translator explains is similar to the English phrase, "good old Meaulnes." ... While there were parts of this book I found a bit bizarre, and others that were slow-moving, overall the writing was so wonderful that I enjoyed it a great deal. (3.5 / 5 stars)

nov 5, 2009, 2:44am (topp)Message 127: juliette07

Loved reading your review as it bought back happy memories. Read this in my youth (in French) and may even re-read it following your nudging my memory!

nov 5, 2009, 4:39am (topp)Message 128: alcottacre

#126: I bought that one last year on someone's (I forget whose) recommendation. I really must find where I put it.

nov 5, 2009, 8:55am (topp)Message 129: tiffin

I've had that sitting here for over a year. Like Stasia I must just dig it out and give it a read. You give such succinct, crisp reviews, Laura, so I always come away with a good sense of the book.

nov 5, 2009, 11:13am (topp)Message 130: lindsacl

>127: would love to be able to read it in French! I did read a couple of very short books in French some time ago, but a full novel ... well, that would be a serious undertaking.
>128: was it citizenkelly? She's the one who turned me on to it. I believe kiwidoc is also a fan.
>129: why thank you! "Succinct and crisp" sounds so much better than "ran out of things to say" !

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, nov 5, 2009, 11:14am.

nov 6, 2009, 4:28am (topp)Message 131: alcottacre

#130: It is possible that it was either of them. I wish I knew :)

nov 8, 2009, 6:13am (topp)Message 132: lindsacl

68. The Sugar House - review

From my review:
This is the third in Antonia White's autobiographical series of novels. In two previous works, Clara Batchelor came of age through convent education and a job as a governess. The Sugar House takes place in 1920, when Clara is 21 years old and working as an actress with a touring company. Her naivete is evident from the start, when jokes about two gay actors go right over her head. Clara shares rooms with an older, brassier actress named Maidie. She also pines after Stephen Tye, an older actor she met prior to leaving on tour. Stephen is full of empty promises and strings Clara along for a while. When the inevitable happens, Clara turns to Archie, a former love who has turned up after a long absence. Clara met Archie while working as a governess, and was even engaged to him for a time. Archie has changed over the years, and not necessarily for the better. Eager to escape theatrical life and yet remain independent from her parents, Clara is blind to Archie's flaws and agrees to marry him. Almost immediately, the couple find themselves severely in debt due to a general unwillingness to live within their means, and exacerbated by Archie's drinking problem. He pours money into hare-brained schemes that go nowhere, and she loses confidence in her own ability to earn a living either by acting or writing.

As Clara and Archie's relationship deteriorates, Clara's depression worsens and she retreats into a bit of a cocoon. Two chance encounters help her emerge from the chrysalis with greater self-awareness. She is no longer a girl, but a woman desirable to other men. The novel concludes with a number of loose ends, but Clara is poised to exercise her independence in completely new ways. The Sugar House reinforces Virginia Woolf's view that that a woman needs "a room of her own" and an independent income, while also highlighting the importance of sexual discovery and independence. (3.5 / 5 stars)

nov 8, 2009, 7:15am (topp)Message 133: juliette07

Interesting review and it has very much inspired me to think about using this trology for the Women Unbound challenge.
I am wondering if there is an LT group for that challenge and if not would it be worth beginning such a group - what think you? Sometimes there is a lot of repetition but on the other hand such a group could develop and bring together an even larger pool of those reading the Women Unbound books.

nov 9, 2009, 7:58am (topp)Message 134: lindsacl

>133: Julie, I'm not aware of an LT group for the Women Unbound challenge. Not a bad idea!

nov 11, 2009, 8:41pm (topp)Message 135: lindsacl

69. Offshore - review

From my review:
"Battersea Reach, ladies and gentlemen. On your right, the artistic colony. Folks live on those boats like they do on the Seine, it's the artist's life they're leading there. Yes, there's people living on those boats." (p. 16)

Along the banks of the Thames, a small group of boats sit permanently anchored, serving as home not to artists, but to a ragtag group of residents who, for various reasons, have chosen to live on the river instead of on land. Their de facto leader is Richard, of the Lord Jim, by far the best-kept boat in the group. Grace is home to Nenna and her two daughters. Her husband has left them and the girls attend school only occasionally. One boat's owner allows stolen goods to be held on board. Another is trying to sell his boat, and hopes none of the other residents will tell prospective buyers about the leak. The characters were largely misfits, with humorous quirks. I was sympathetic towards Nenna, with her general awkwardness, her difficulty raising young daughters alone, and and her inability to rescue her marriage.

Unfortunately however, the central theme of the novel eluded me. There were also several loose ends and incongruities in the plot. It was a light and sometimes pleasant read, but I am positively baffled as to how it won the Booker Prize. Ah well, at least it was short. (2.5 / 5 stars)

nov 11, 2009, 9:13pm (topp)Message 136: tiffin

Well of course I had to read all of the reviews about it, after that. It seems to sweep people away or leave them scratching their heads. I do like the sound of it. Did you read it because it is a Booker winner?

nov 12, 2009, 12:12pm (topp)Message 137: lindsacl

>136: yes I did, Tui ... I'm in dogged pursuit of reading all 42 winners (should get there in 2010, including the 43rd). It was quirky and fun in its way. I think the fact it won the Booker heightened my expectations. It just struck me that if it hadn't won, I might have rated it higher. That makes no sense, but I will staunchly defend my right to think strangely at times!

nov 13, 2009, 7:34am (topp)Message 138: alcottacre

Having had similar experiences with several of the Booker prize winners, Laura, I completely understand the bafflement as to how it won the prize, lol.

nov 13, 2009, 11:25am (topp)Message 139: brenzi

ditto what stasia said

nov 13, 2009, 12:14pm (topp)Message 140: lindsacl

I have to say Offshore looked especially weak since the previous Booker winner I'd read was Wolf Hall!

nov 14, 2009, 12:36pm (topp)Message 141: Soupdragon

I bought this cheap from a charity shop and it went straight to the bottom of my TBR pile. I think I might actually get around to reading it now, underwhelmed though you were Laura, if only to satisfy my curiosity!

I think that big Booker expectation hanging over it probably has influenced readers' perceptions. Like Tiffin, I went onto read the other reviews and noticed that the less favourable ones mentioned the Booker with a similar baffled air. The most enthusiastic one didn't mention it at all!

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, nov 14, 2009, 12:43pm.

nov 14, 2009, 1:41pm (topp)Message 142: Whisper1

I'm stopping by to say thanks for your excellent review of Wolf Hall. I finished this book a few days ago. It is as good as your comments indicated!

nov 14, 2009, 2:48pm (topp)Message 143: lindsacl

>141: Soup, it's a short read so it would be easy enough to satisfy your curiosity, especially if you're up for something quirky. Interesting comments on the other reviews though.

>142: I'm so glad you enjoyed it!

nov 18, 2009, 12:40pm (topp)Message 144: laytonwoman3rd

Just catching up with your thread---you've read some smashing stuff in the last month, my girl. Of course, I'm eagerly looking forward to my read of Wolf Hall, but now I'm also kind of itching to read the Antonia White books, which I've had for quite some time.

nov 18, 2009, 12:44pm (topp)Message 145: lindsacl

Happy to help increase your TBR pile ;-)

nov 20, 2009, 8:45pm (topp)Message 146: lindsacl

70. Angle of Repose - review

From my review: Lyman Ward is writing a family history. More specifically, it's the story of a marriage between his grandmother (Susan Burling Ward) and grandfather (Oliver Ward) who lived in the American West in the late 1800s. Day after day, Lyman pores over family records, news clippings, and letters, and records his thoughts on cassette tapes. Lyman lives alone, is out of touch with his family, and severely disabled due to a bone disease. ... I absolutely loved this book. The prose captured me instantly, and I became completely wrapped up both in Lyman's California of 1970, and the dusty Victorian mining camps. I identified strongly with Susan: her feelings of isolation, her persistence in keeping her artistic talents fresh, her devotion to her family, her longing for intellectual stimulation. And my heart went out to Lyman, with his own isolation and struggles with a failing body. These characters were so real to me; during the week it took me to read this book, I thought about them all the time. Towards the end, I wanted to prolong the relationship -- instead of rushing to finish, I read the last 50 pages very slowly, setting the book aside to make it last. This will undoubtedly make my "Top 10" list for the year. (5 / 5 stars)

nov 20, 2009, 9:20pm (topp)Message 147: brenzi

Well Laura for once you are not increasing my TBR pile because I read this gem along with a bunch of WallaceStegner's other work in the early 90's. Like you, I loved this one and it actually was my favorite. As a matter of fact after reading your excellent review I think it may be time for a reread. So....I guess you managed to add to the pile after all. Hmmm.

nov 20, 2009, 10:27pm (topp)Message 148: tiffin

What an absolutely stunning review, Laura. Well done, you!

nov 20, 2009, 10:40pm (topp)Message 149: VisibleGhost

Damn, now you've made me want to reread Angle of Repose.

nov 21, 2009, 2:46am (topp)Message 150: alcottacre

Me, too.

nov 21, 2009, 4:28am (topp)Message 151: judylou

Me three!

nov 21, 2009, 6:09am (topp)Message 152: lindsacl

Hooray !!!

nov 21, 2009, 12:27pm (topp)Message 153: tymfos

What a stunning review! And thank you for adding something to my wishlist that our local library actually has on the shelf!

nov 21, 2009, 4:57pm (topp)Message 154: pamelad

Laura, since you enjoyed Empire Falls you might like Straight Man. It's my favourite of Russo's books.

nov 23, 2009, 10:29am (topp)Message 155: dchaikin

Fantastic review of Angle of Repose - congrats on the hot review.

nov 23, 2009, 3:03pm (topp)Message 156: lindsacl

Thank you dchaikin!

nov 23, 2009, 3:08pm (topp)Message 157: lindsacl

71. A Short History of Tractors in Ukrainian - review

My review:
Oh, puh-leeze. This book annoyed me; let me count the ways.

First, we have two middle-aged sisters, Vera and Nadia, who emigrated from Ukraine to UK as children. They don't get along. And they have much angst about this but seem powerless to change their relationship.

Second, we have their father, Nikolai, an elderly widower also living in the UK. He's lonely and a bit naive. And he's writing a history of tractors, and relates the development of the tractor to other events in history. Actually, Nikolai didn't annoy me. I felt sorry for him. Let's move on.

Third, there's Valentina, a 30-something Ukrainian blond bombshell. She has a young son and very large breasts. Valentina convinces Nikolai to marry her in order to provide legal residency and an education for her son. As I mentioned, Nikolai is lonely and naive. And he likes her breasts. So he agrees.

Back to Vera and Nadia. Their father's marriage causes them even more angst. This, I could understand because Valentina turns out to be after Nikolai's money. And she spends it like there's no tomorrow. But Vera and Nadia? They whine, and talk, and fight with one another. Then they whine, and talk some more. Eventually they do something about the situation.

There were some interesting elements to this book, like gaining some understanding of Ukrainian political events that led to the family's relocation in the 1940s. And there was a great deal of humor in the book, especially the portrayal of Valentina who was really over the top. But almost from the beginning, I felt like I knew where the story would go. And the dynamics between the sisters bored me. When the "big reveal" came, which explained why the two were so different in a way that was supposed to be oh so emotional, it just left me flat. (2 / 5 stars)

nov 23, 2009, 4:27pm (topp)Message 158: tiffin

Did they run over Valentina with a tractor?

ETA: you can tell me, because I'm deffo not going to read this one.

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, nov 23, 2009, 4:28pm.

nov 23, 2009, 5:11pm (topp)Message 159: pamelad

Tui, Laura hated it, but I quite enjoyed it. Different frame of reference.

Laura, such a pragmatic review! I wish you could have got in there to sort those sisters out!

nov 23, 2009, 9:13pm (topp)Message 160: lindsacl

Tui, you make me laugh!
Pam, isn't it fascinating how people can have such different impressions of the same book?!

nov 26, 2009, 7:53pm (topp)Message 161: lindsacl

72. The Emperor's Children - review

My review:
Marina, Danielle, and Julius were classmates at Brown University and are all now approaching 30, and making their way in New York City. Marina is the daughter of Murray Thwaite, a famous journalist. She has been working on her first book for many years, and has never held a "real job." She lives with her parents, having recently moved back home after ending a long-term relationship. Julius is a gay freelance writer who lives lives in a squalid apartment and finds work through a temp agency while waiting for his next writing assignments. Danielle produces television programs, and is the only one with a steady income. The Emperor's Children follows these three over the course of a year. While they rarely cross paths in their day-to-day lives, the bonds of friendship are strong and they do call on each other for help and support. Another key figure in this story is Frederick "Bootie" Tubb, Murray's nephew, who has dropped out of university, and came to New York hoping to find himself and make a living. Murray provides Bootie a place to live, and takes him on as his secretary. Danielle is instrumental in finding Marina a job with a magazine startup, and Marina offers both Julius and Bootie the chance to write an article for the inaugural issue. Julius meets romantic interest David through one of his temp jobs, and begins to move in very different social circles. All of the young people look up to Murray as a role model of the successful and wealthy writer. Meanwhile, Murray is dealing with a bit of a mid-life crisis, and struggles to control everyone around him.

Messud draws an intriguing portrait of a certain social class. The characters in this novel are are shallow, superficial, and materialistic. It was difficult to care much about any of them, but I still found myself oddly drawn to their stories -- like watching an impending train wreck. But this book takes place in 2001 (and remember, in New York City). So of course September 11 was like the elephant in the room the entire time I was reading this book. On several instances, characters discussed events planned for September, which I just knew wouldn't turn out as planned. I was curious how Messud would address this pivotal event in the novel. After finishing the book I was left wondering if setting the novel in 2001 was just an afterthought, a convenient way to tie up the plot. The year is casually thrown into the text about 50 pages in. September 11 occurs 60 pages from the end of the book, and while it understandably changes the characters' lives, it was an all-too-easy way to catalyze certain events and bring the novel to a close. While this was a light read and somewhat pleasurable, it wasn't quite my thing. (2.5 / 5 stars)

nov 27, 2009, 7:53am (topp)Message 162: rebeccanyc

Laura, as you know, I was waiting for your review of this one! You are kinder to it than I would have been, and I definitely, perhaps as a New Yorker, feel the 9/11 material was totally gratuitous and also a little bizarre.

des 2, 2009, 8:43pm (topp)Message 163: lindsacl

73. Saville - review

This book reads like a student's report of "What I did on my Summer Vacation": a chronology of events told in a factual style with absolutely no drama whatsoever. The student essay has a distinct advantage: it's short. Saville, on the other hand, is a 500-page tome that plods through the life of Colin Saville. The story opens with his parents moving into a squalid home in a Yorkshire mining village. They soon have a child -- Colin's older brother, Andrew, who died before Colin was born. And then Colin comes into the world, grows up, and is awarded a scholarship to go to a decent grammar school. He has various friends, some from his village and others from his school. He works summer jobs. He decides to attend a 2-year college instead of university. He meets various young ladies. He tries hard to overcome his humble origins.

And I'm sorry, but it's all dreadfully dull. There's not a single moment of suspense, tension, or emotion. There were several occasions where I thought a subplot might actually be going somewhere: perhaps a character would turn out to be evil, or some tragedy would befall the Saville family. But no -- even Andrew's death was treated matter-of-factly, and was not mentioned again until Colin was about 20 years old. When he told his girlfriend that his brother's death had a profound impact on his life, all I could say was, "huh?" I'm not sure how I finished it, and I confess to skimming the last 100 pages.

This book suffered significantly from an overdone theme ("dreary English mining village"), coupled with a semi-autobiographical story that was definitely of more interest to the author than it would be to anyone else. (2.5 / 5 stars)

des 2, 2009, 8:59pm (topp)Message 164: Milda-TX

oh dear. thanks for the warning!

des 2, 2009, 9:18pm (topp)Message 165: Whisper1

Laura

Hang in there...only two more books to go to reach the goal. I follow your thread religiously and add many of your books to my tbr pile. I trust your recommendations and enjoy your comments!

des 2, 2009, 9:20pm (topp)Message 166: brenzi

Laura ,

If I'm not mistaken you've had three totally unremarkable reads in a row after reading the astonishingly good Angle of Repose. Let's see "Just left me flat," "wasn't quite my thing," and "of more interest to the author than it would be to anyone else." Sounds like you're due for a really good read next. I've got my fingers crossed for you ;)

des 2, 2009, 10:30pm (topp)Message 167: arubabookwoman

Whoa--I've had Saville on my list of books to look for for many years, because it sounded interesting and it was a prize (Booker?) winner. Thanks for the warning. At last I have a book to remove from that list!

des 3, 2009, 5:27am (topp)Message 168: alcottacre

Sorry that you had to slog your way through Saville. I hope your next read is better for you!

des 3, 2009, 7:54am (topp)Message 169: lindsacl

>165: Oh thank you Whisper1! You're very kind
>166: Bonnie, don't I know it. It's been a rough go since the Stegner. So my current book is much more of a comfort read, a mystery. It may not be a 5-star Angle of Repose, but it won't be a slog through molasses, either.
>167: I read it precisely because it was a Booker winner, and I'm working my way through the list. So I can cheerfully cross this one off, but it was far from the best Booker I've ever read!
>168: I appreciate your sympathy!

des 6, 2009, 9:36pm (topp)Message 170: lindsacl

74. In the Bleak Midwinter - review

Clare Fergusson, an Episcopal priest in her mid-30s, has recently arrived in Millers Kill, NY to serve the congregation at St. Alban's. When a newborn baby is left on the church doorstep, she meets police chief Russ Van Alstyne, and thus begins their crime-solving partnership. In trying to find the baby's parents, they uncover a murder, which naturally leads to further investigation There are many potential suspects, and plenty of interesting developments that keep the story moving.

Clare and Russ, on the surface, appear to be an improbable partnership. However, prior to joining the clergy Clare served in the Army, and was trained in survival skills. Russ is a Vietnam veteran and has lived in Millers Kill for years. He feels a strong sense of ownership over the town and its inhabitants. As a minister, Clare has unique access to members of her congregation, which is both a blessing and a curse. Oh, and there's a little frisson of attraction between Clare and Russ, which adds an element of "will they or won't they" to the novel. They make a good pair.

And Spencer-Fleming kept me guessing all the way to the end. The last 100 pages or so were filled with suspense, as all the pieces began to fall into place. This was a very well-written, character-driven mystery and I'm looking forward to reading the next in the series. (3.5 / 5 stars)

des 6, 2009, 10:57pm (topp)Message 171: tymfos

Nice review! I really enjoy the mysteries with Clare and Russ. They are among my favorite series.

Hey, 1 more book and you hit the big #75! :)

ETA for typos

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, des 6, 2009, 10:58pm.

des 7, 2009, 2:09am (topp)Message 172: alcottacre

I also enjoy the Spencer-Fleming mysteries. I am glad you enjoyed In the Bleak Midwinter.

I will join Terri in offering an early Congratulations on 75.

des 7, 2009, 8:25am (topp)Message 173: lindsacl

Yes, I'm getting close to 75 now ... however, I decided to finish a book that I counted in July. I only read half of it, but that was 228 pages so it seemed justified to add it to my list. Now I've decided to read the remainder. So my big 75 celebration will have to wait a bit!

des 7, 2009, 8:33am (topp)Message 174: Whisper1

Happy almost 75. Your LT friends will be here to help celebrate the victory!

des 7, 2009, 10:48am (topp)Message 175: Donna828

>173: Hmmm....and I am wondering what book you put down in July and felt calling to you these five months later. I'm glad to see I'm not the only one with a book conscience!

des 11, 2009, 7:28pm (topp)Message 176: lindsacl

Update on book #44:
I originally posted about this book here, writing it off as my first (and only!) "DNF" of the year. But I kept thinking about it, and when the Women Unbound reading challenge came along it seemed a good time to finish it.

The Judge - review

This novel is primarily the story of two strong women. Ellen Melville is 17 years old, working as a typist in an Edinburgh legal office by day and participating in suffragist meetings and demonstrations nights and weekends. She is outspoken and confident, and naive enough to be surprised by hostile crowds during demonstrations. She is also completely unaware of her effect on the opposite sex. The men in the office treat her as an object, except for Richard Yaverland, a client of the firm. Richard is much older than Ellen, and more worldly, but also more liberal in his political views. When Ellen and Richard decide to marry, they journey to the south of England to meet Richard's mother, Marion.

The first half of this book is Ellen's story; the second half belongs to Marion. Richard and his mother are extremely close -- in fact, their relationship borders on the unhealthy. Marion has strong, mixed emotions about Richard and Ellen's relationship. She professes to love Ellen almost at first sight, and yet inwardly wrestles with the impact that marriage will have on Marion's relationship with her son. Just as I was asking myself, "What is this woman's problem?", Marion's "back story" was revealed in the form of one long, sleepless night filled with memories going back to Marion's youth. She had been in love with Harry, a young squire, who left for military service. Then Marion learned she was pregnant. She was subject to public shame, including an incident in which she was stoned by townspeople. For her own safety she entered into marriage with a man who offered her security and didn't even require that they live together. Marion doted on the illegitimate Richard, and found herself completely unable to love a second child borne of her marriage. As the two children came of age they were treated quite differently, and this had serious consequences when they reached adulthood. As Marion herself said, "Every mother is a judge who sentences the children for the sins of the father." (p.346)

Rebecca West was a pioneer in feminist literature who knew from personal experience what it meant to be an outspoken, strong woman. Published in 1922, The Judge portrays two such women and shows how society failed each of them. However, while the book is well-written, the prose is dense and requires concentration. The ending is abrupt and felt somewhat contrived. I would not consider this West's best work, but for those who would like to read more early 20th century novels written by women,it's worth a try. (3 / 5 stars)

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, des 11, 2009, 10:24pm.

des 15, 2009, 4:33pm (topp)Message 177: tiffin

Good for you for ploughing on to the end. Not sure I want to tackle this one ever.

des 16, 2009, 1:44am (topp)Message 178: allthesedarnbooks

Hmmm. The Judge sounds interesting, like something I would enjoy discussing if I were reading it for a class, but I don't know as it's something I'll try reading on my own. Thanks for the review, tho!

des 17, 2009, 8:53pm (topp)Message 179: lindsacl

75. Crossriggs - review

Alexandra Hope is a 30-ish unmarried woman living with her father in the village of Crossriggs, near Edinburgh. When her older sister Matilda is widowed, she and her 5 children return to Crossriggs to live at home. The two sisters are close, but couldn't be more different. Matilda is a bit of a doormat, and rarely expresses her own thoughts. In fact, Matilda generally agreed with everyone about everything, even if she happened to hold another opinion... (p. 35). Alex is strong and independent, and has rejected proposals rather than using marriage to achieve financial security. Recognizing that the new arrivals will stretch the family's ability to make ends meet, she finds employment in daily "read aloud" sessions with a Admiral Cassilis, an elderly, wealthy blind man.

Supporting the two sisters are a strong cast of village locals, many of whom are quite amusing. For example, Alex and Matilda's father is a vegetarian, which from the tone of the novel, must have been quite unusual in Victorian England. And Mr. Hope (known to many as "Old Hopeless") takes it a step further by declaring himself a "fruitarian" and living off garden apples past their prime. He engages in humorous attempts to educate house guests by subjecting them to his favorite foods. And then there is Miss Bessie Reid, a spinster of a certain age:
Miss Bessie Reid -- good woman! -- was skilled in all the little arts that make home hideous. There was a specimen of her handiwork at every turn -- a painted tambourine here, a stark water-colour there, whilst miniature animals in crockery seemed to crawl on every ledge. ... Taste, I suppose, is only a constant delicate expression of opinion, and Miss Bessie's opinions -- poor dear! -- must have been singularly confused. (p. 141)

On her first visit to the Admiral, Alex meets his grandson Van, who is new to Crossriggs. Van is several years younger than Alex, but he is immediately attracted to her. She is oblivious to his attentions, first because of the age difference, and second because Alex herself has strong affections for Robert Maitland. Maitland is a long-standing family friend and the attraction is mutual. He is, however, married. Both Maitland and Alex take great pains to conceal their affections, even from each other. And yet Alex is both sufficiently devoted and independent to rebuff Van's advances. As the family's fortunes ebb and flow, Alex finds additional opportunities to earn income through public readings, and teaching in town. Being the breadwinner for such a large family begins to take its toll. And even as Alex shows clear signs of stress and fatigue, the annoyingly helpless Matilda just "tut tuts" and lectures Alex, while doing absolutely nothing to help provide for the family.

On the surface, this novel appears to be focused on Alex's love interests: will she and Maitland find a way to get together? Will she choose Van? But by the end of this book, it's clear the Findlater sisters were exploring much more important points. What is more important: money, or loving relationships? Why do women feel they have to marry in order to be safe and secure? Can a woman have a career? Why is it so difficult for a woman to live independently in society? And even though women have made incredible strides since the publication of Crossriggs in 1908, we still don't have good answers to those questions. (4 / 5 stars)

des 17, 2009, 9:14pm (topp)Message 180: tiffin

#75 WTG!!! And a good sounding one it is too. Wonderful reading this year for you, Laura.

des 17, 2009, 9:15pm (topp)Message 181: lindsacl

Thank you Tui! And I'm not done yet ... ;-)
I've just begun 2 weeks' vacation so I expect that even with the holidays I'll be doing quite a bit of reading. ooh la la !!

des 18, 2009, 1:08am (topp)Message 182: alcottacre


des 18, 2009, 2:38am (topp)Message 183: juliette07

Congratulations Laura - awesome!!!

des 18, 2009, 8:32am (topp)Message 184: drneutron

Congrats!

des 18, 2009, 9:48am (topp)Message 185: lindsacl

Thanks everyone!

des 18, 2009, 9:52am (topp)Message 186: brenzi

Excellent job Laura. I enjoy reading your reviews too and will look forward to them in the coming year.

des 18, 2009, 1:20pm (topp)Message 187: allthesedarnbooks

Congrats on reaching 75!!! Can't wait to see what you read next.

des 18, 2009, 2:39pm (topp)Message 188: tymfos

Hooray! Congrats on reaching #75!

des 18, 2009, 5:41pm (topp)Message 189: pamelad

Congratulations Laura, and thanks for some great reviews.

des 18, 2009, 7:32pm (topp)Message 190: FlossieT

**75** YAY! Congratulations - and I have to say, that book sounds FABULOUS. Definitely going to go ferret it out (I'm already assuming, when I see the lovely VMC jacket, that it's ILL for me all the way...)

des 18, 2009, 7:36pm (topp)Message 191: Whisper1

Congratulations! I've added many of your books to my list this year!

des 18, 2009, 9:44pm (topp)Message 192: lindsacl

You guys are great! Thanks so much for stopping by!

des 19, 2009, 6:35pm (topp)Message 193: lindsacl

76. The Hunger Games - review

Katniss Everdeen lives in District 12 of Panem, a post-apocalyptic North America divided into 12 districts. District 12 is a poor district with coal mining as its primary industry. Since her father's death in the mines, Katniss has served as head of her family, which includes her mother and younger sister, Prim. Katniss hunts in the woods with her friend Gale, and trades some of the meat in the market in order to meet most of the family's needs. Katniss is a tough cookie, having had to grow up far too soon. She resents her mother, who fell into deep depression when her husband died. But she adores Prim and would do anything for her.

In this dystopian world there is an annual tournament, known as The Hunger Games, in which two youths from each district compete. There's just one thing: the winner of the competition is the one who survives. The children are chosen by lottery -- one boy and one girl from each district -- and are then whisked away to the Capitol to prepare for the games. When Prim's name is drawn, Katniss instantly steps in to take her place. She is accompanied by Peeta, a boy she barely knows, but who has apparently had eyes for Katniss for a very long time. Katniss' feelings are conflicted: on the one hand, she feels quite vulnerable and needs a friend; on the other, she knows they will soon be fighting against each other for their lives. When they arrive at the Capitol they go through training programs, make public appearances, and develop their strategy with help from District 12 mentors.

And then the games begin, and my plot summary ends. The story is filled with suspense, and even though I had a suspicion that things would turn out OK, at no time was I certain. The premise is frightening and yet, in my bleaker moments, I can almost envision a world that puts their children at risk in this way. The contestants are faced with a myriad of moral dilemmas that could be thought-provoking for the reader -- especially the young adults for whom this book is written. There's now a sequel to The Hunger Games, and I liked this first book well enough to be interested in a second helping. (3.5 / 5 stars)

des 20, 2009, 6:15pm (topp)Message 194: brenzi

Thanks for your review Linda. I've wondered about this one although dystopian is not usually my cup of tea. However, your review moves me closer to trying it.

Denne beskjeden har blitt redigert av forfatteren, des 20, 2009, 6:16pm.

des 20, 2009, 8:36pm (topp)Message 195: wookiebender

Congratulations on making 75, and beyond, Laura!

des 21, 2009, 9:44am (topp)Message 196: lindsacl

Thank you ... !

77. A Room with a View - review

Well, let me begin by saying I love the 1985 Merchant Ivory film adaptation of this book, and have seen it more times than I can count. And because of that, it was next to impossible to read this book without humming Puccini's O Mio Babbino Caro, and imagining the characters exactly as portrayed by the excellent cast.

Lucy Honeychurch is a young Victorian woman who travels to Florence, Italy with her cousin Charlotte as chaperon. There they meet a host of English people also on holiday, including the Reverend Beebe who has just taken up a position in Lucy's home village, a flamboyant woman novelist named Eleanor Lavish, and the Emersons, a father and son. On arrival at their pension, Lucy and Charlotte find their rooms are not what had been promised. Most importantly, there is no view. The Emersons offer to exchange rooms, creating a comedy of manners as Charlotte abhors feeling obligated to anyone, not the least people like George and his father, whom she judges to be "common." However, there is an attraction between Lucy and George, which Lucy tries to deny. On returning home she is courted by the arrogant and class-conscious Cecil Vyse, and agrees to marry him as a way of putting her attraction for George out of her mind. But of course that's not the end of the story, and when George and his father appear on the scene in England, Lucy has to come to terms with her own feelings and the importance of making choices guided by one's own sense of right and wrong.

I tried to consider this book on its own merits: does Forster's novel stand on its own? I simply couldn't do it. The film is so true to the book; much of the dialogue went directly into the script. I can't quite say why, but I am fairly certain that if I hadn't seen the film I would not have enjoyed this book as much as I did. So I am left giving this book a respectable rating, while urging anyone who has not seen the film to do so ... you will not be disappointed. (3 / 5 stars)

des 21, 2009, 1:33pm (topp)Message 197: alcottacre

#196: I have not seen the film, so perhaps I should read the book first and then view the film. I actually own the book although I have not read it yet.

I går, 7:29pm (topp)Message 198: FlossieT

I borrowed the book from my mum last year shortly before a trip to Florence but never got round to reading. I haven't seen the film, but on the basis of your review, will hold off doing so until I've had a chance to read the book first; it's great that you feel that the film is true to the book, but I want to have my own shot at it first ;-)

I går, 9:25pm (topp)Message 199: lindsacl

>197, 198: I generally prefer to read books before seeing the movie, so I agree with your idea!

I går, 10:01pm (topp)Message 200: tiffin

I did it the other way around, having studied the book as an undergrad. I liked it a lot then but when I saw the movie, it went into technicolour, so to speak, even though we had dug into it fairly well in seminars. I think the two mediums really compliment each other in this case.

I dag, 8:53pm (topp)Message 201: lindsacl

78. The Hiding Place - review

Corrie ten Boom and her family operated an underground movement in Holland during World War II, providing safe passage to Jews during the German occupation. Corrie's father owned a watch repair business; Corrie and her older sister Betsie remained unmarried and assisted their father in the shop. They were well-known for their kindness and hospitality, so it was natural for neighbors to turn to them for help. As they developed connections with others involved in the movement, their operation increased in scope and required both more sophisticated methods and more caution. A secret room was built in the house to hide the occupants in case of a raid. A buzzer system was installed to alert occupants to a raid or other emergency, and drills were held to ensure people could hide without leaving evidence. Signals were arranged to communicate when it was safe to enter the house.

The ten Boom family performed an important ministry during the war, but eventually the authorities became aware of their work and the family was arrested and taken to a political prisoner camp. Corrie and Betsie ten Boom spent nearly a year in a series of prison camps, under appalling conditions. Their deep Christian faith was key to survival. After the war, Corrie set up rehabilitation centers in the Netherlands, lectured about her experience, and taught others based on the Christian Gospels and themes of forgiveness. Corrie ten Boom's faith and ability to forgive are an inspiration; it takes an extraordinary person to survive such a harrowing experience and be able to forgive your persecutors.

The Hiding Place was an interesting memoir from a dark time in the history of humankind. (3 / 5 stars)

I dag, 9:52pm (topp)Message 202: alcottacre

#201: I read that one more years ago than I care to remember. Seems like it is due for a re-read!

(tilbake til toppen)

Debug test: your member name is:

Touchstone works

Forfattere av viktige verk

Ruth Adam
Alain-Fournier
Alan Bennett
Corrie ten Boom
Willa Cather
Raymond Chandler
J. M. Coetzee
Suzanne Collins
Roddy Doyle
Daphne Du Maurier
William Fiennes
Mary Findlater
Penelope Fitzgerald
E. M. Forster
Paul Gallico
Stella Gibbons
William Golding
Henry James
Marina Lewycka
Hilary Mantel
Daphne Du Maurier
Claire Messud
DBC Pierre
E. Arnot Robertson
Richard Russo
Julia Spencer-Fleming
Wallace Stegner
David Storey
Elizabeth Strout
Faith Sullivan
Rebecca West
Antonia White
Virginia Woolf
Richard Yates
E. H. Young
Hjelp/Ofte Stilte Spørsmål (OSS) | Om | Personvern/Brukervilkår | Blogg | Kontakt | LibraryThing.com | APIs | WikiThing | Allmennkunnskap | 46,689,272 bøker!